Monthly Failure Report: February 2026

No Response From February 2025:

Dan Hampton

Jordan Staal

Aroldis Chapman

Charlie Frye

J.T. Snow

Jeff Nelson

Wayne Gretzky

Michael Young

Dan Dierdorf

Tom Kelly Rookie Card

Here's a return from Tom Kelly that came in one of those "We Care" bags.  The card somehow escaped unscathed.  Thanks, Tom!

Mailed: 11-28-25
Received Back: 2-27-26
Turnaround Time: 91 Days

Brett Butler Rookie

Here's a pretty cool pre-rookie card that 17-year MLB Veteran and one-time All-Star Brett Butler signed.  Thanks, Brett!

Mailed: 6-9-25
Received Back: 2-21-26
Turnaround Time: 258 Days

Jan Stenerud Rookie

Hall of Fame Kicker Jan Stenerud signed his 1970 Topps Rookie Card for $10, though his fee for that has now apparently gone up to $25.  Thanks, Jan!

Mailed: 2-9-26
Received Back: 2-21-26
Turnaround Time: 12 Days

Sweet Lou Piniella Rookie

Sweet Lou signed his 1964 Topps Rookie Card for $5.  There's a chance that he will eventually get into the Hall of Fame.  He was a great player and a great manager.  Thanks, Lou!

Mailed: 2-9-26
Received Back: 2-20-26
Turnaround Time: 11 Days

Javon Walker

Javon Walker compiled 267 receptions for 4,011 yards and 31 TDs during his eight NFL seasons.  He signed two cards, including a rookie card.  Thanks, Javon!

Mailed: 1-20-26
Received Back: 2-20-26
Turnaround Time: 31 Days

Rolf Benirschke Rookie

Here's a great return from 10-year NFL veteran and one-time Pro Bowl Kicker Rolf Benirschke.  Thanks, Rolf!

Mailed: 2-9-26
Received Back: 2-17-26
Turnaround Time: 8 Days