Here's an amazing return from Hall of Famer Trevor Hoffman, who is perhaps the second best closer of all time. A seven-time All-Star, Hoffman won 61 games and saved 601 games during his 18 MLB seasons, sporting a 2.87 ERA. He also saved four postseason games. Thanks, Trevor!
Mailed: 9-28-26
Received Back: 10-31-26
Turnaround Time: 33 Days
No Response From October 2025:
Jim Hart
Andre Reed
Greg Vaughn
Grant Hill
No Response From September 2025:
Elvis Andrus
Jacob Wilson
Deron Cherry
Mailed: 4-28-25
Received Back: 9-10-26
Turnaround Time: 500 Days
No Response From August 2025:
Mickey Morandini
Steve Spurrier
Taye Diggs
Brett Hull
Dustin Pedroia
Jeff Bagwell
Warren Sapp
Here's an amazing return from Billy Ripken, who signed his famous 1989 Fleer card, although this is the version with the black box, because I didn't want to send the "FF" error card through the mail. The brother of Cal Ripken, Jr., Billy played in twelve MLB seasons for four teams, finishing with a career .247 batting average. Thanks, Billy!
Mailed: 11-28-25
Received Back: 8-17-26
Turnaround Time: 264 Days
