Monthly Failure Report: July 2024

No Response From July 2023:

Kelly Gruber
Brian Mitchell

Mo Vaughn

A one-time MVP and three-time All-Star, Mo Vaughn hit 328 Home Runs during his 12 MLB seasons with the Red Sox, Angels, and Mets.  He had a respectable .293 batting average to go along with 1,064 RBI.  He signed his 1990 Bowman Rookie Card.  Thanks, Mo!

Mailed: 7-17-24
Received Back: 7-29-24
Turnaround Time: 12 Days

Frank Tanana Rookie

Frank Tanana completes the back-to-back 1974 Topps Rookie returns.  Can you tell I found a vintage bargain box at a local card show?  I always thought that Tanana had a borderline Hall of Fame case with his 240 Wins and 2,773 Strikeouts, but he may always be in that next tier that just didn't quite make it into the Hall.  Thanks, Frank!

Mailed: 7-10-24
Received Back: 7-27-24
Turnaround Time: 17 Days

Andy Thornton

Here's a nice return from Andre Thornton, who signed two of his 1974 Topps Rookie Cards.  Thanks, Andre!

Mailed: 7-10-24
Received Back: 7-25-24
Turnaround Time: 15 Days

Bert Campaneris Rookie

Here's another great return from Bert Campaneris on his 1965 Topps Rookie Card.  He charges $5 per card to sign through the mail.  Thanks, Bert!

Mailed: 7-10-24
Received Back: 7-23-24
Turnaround Time: 13 Days

Robby Richardson

Here's another great return from Bobby Richardson, who signed and inscribed his 1962 Topps Card!  He also sent a great Christian tract about Mickey Mantle and left a nice note on that as well.  The man is an ATTM legend.  Thanks, Bobby!

Mailed: 7-10-24
Received Back: 7-22-24
Turnaround Time: 12 Days

Hawk Tuah

Here's another great return from The Hawk, Andre Dawson!  I recently picked up this 1977 Topps Rookie Card and decided to send it off to him to get it signed for $10, which is well worth it.  Thanks, Andre!

Mailed: 7-1-24
Received Back: 7-13-24
Turnaround Time: 12 Days